Patsy’s Pizzeria of New Rochelle

Patsy’s Pizzeria of New Rochelle

2 Pelham Rd, New Rochelle, NY 10801, United States

Italian restaurant, Bar, Family restaurant
(1405)
Share Your Experience

About This Place

Nestled in the heart of New Rochelle, Patsy’s Pizzeria of New Rochelle stands as a cherished Italian restaurant and family dining destination that delights guests with authentic flavors and warm hospitality. This inviting eatery masterfully combines classic Italian culinary traditions with a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere and even a charming bar setting, making it a perfect spot whether you’re planning a casual lunch by the water or a romantic evening out.

Step inside, and you’ll immediately notice the ambiance: peaceful, welcoming, and thoughtfully arranged to enhance your dining experience. Guests can enjoy their meals in cozy indoor spaces or savor the delightful side dining area that offers breathtaking views overlooking the water—an ideal backdrop for both celebrations and quiet meals. Customers rave about the attentive and genuine service, where staff makes you feel not just a patron but a special guest, adding an authentic layer to the overall experience.

When it comes to the menu, Patsy’s truly shines with an exceptional array of Italian classics prepared with care and a touch of passion. Among the standouts is the Chicken Scarpariello, a beautifully roasted half chicken infused with the bold flavors of sweet and spicy sausage, tender potatoes, and zesty cherry peppers—finished with a bright white wine lemon broth that lingers on the palate. Though it carries a spicy kick, it’s a dish that customers find memorable and deeply satisfying.

For those seeking something lighter yet equally delectable, the Chicken Martini offers a delightful twist—parmesan-crusted chicken breast served with a luscious lemon butter sauce alongside roasted potatoes and fresh spinach. Its richness balanced with citrus notes has made it a fan favorite time and again, praised for perfectly marrying comfort and elegance.

Vegetarian options are thoughtfully crafted as well, with the Eggplant Parmesan and a unique roasted eggplant sandwich that pairs delicate, savory layers with fresh sides like a crisp Caesar salad. Their classic pizza also commands attention, noted for its perfectly crunchy crust, flavorful sauce, and the balanced, non-greasy finish that makes you savor every bite.

Families appreciate the dedicated kids’ menu featuring favorites such as chicken parmigiana, pasta with meatballs or marinara, small classic pizzas, and more, ensuring younger guests enjoy delicious, age-appropriate meals that please picky eaters without sacrificing quality.

Beverage options include classic sodas with a twist—many visitors highlight the Blue Coco drink for its refreshing and vibrant flavor, a perfect companion to their savory selections.

What truly elevates Patsy’s Pizzeria is not just the quality and authenticity of the food but the genuine, heartfelt service that transforms each visit into a memorable occasion. Reviewers consistently note the professionalism and warmth of the staff—whether it’s a welcome at a romantic dinner or accommodating a large party with clear honesty and care. The combination of great food, picturesque settings, and outstanding service creates an experience that guests want to return to again and again.

For anyone seeking an Italian dining experience steeped in tradition but served with modern warmth, Patsy’s Pizzeria of New Rochelle promises a satisfying culinary journey that speaks to both the comforting and the refined pleasures of Italy’s beloved cuisine.

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance Wheelchair-accessible seating Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Outdoor seating Offers kerbside pickup No-contact delivery Offers delivery Offers takeaway Serves dine-in
Highlights
Good for watching sport
Offerings
Serves alcohol Serves beer Serves cocktails Serves coffee Serves comfort food Serves food Serves happy-hour drinks Serves happy-hour food Serves late-night food Serves small plates Serves spirits Serves wine
Dining options
Serves breakfast Serves brunch Serves lunch Serves dinner Catering Serves dessert Seating
Amenities
Bar on site Toilet Wi-Fi Free Wi-Fi
Crowd
Family friendly LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Accepts debit cards Accepts NFC mobile payments Credit cards
Children
Good for kids High chairs available Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking Free parking lot On-site parking Plenty of parking Valet parking
Pets
Dogs allowed

Map & Directions

Visitor Reviews

  • Escogida por Misericordia
    4 week ago

    I loved my first experience at Patsy, the ambiance was perfect, peaceful and romantic. Food was perfect, my plate was the Chicken Scarpariello I liked it but it was too spicy for me. As for my husband he had the chicken Martini and he loved it. The customer service was marvelous, very attentive welcoming staffs, which made us feel very special to be there. We will definitely be returning.

  • Joann Bates
    1 month ago

    Had a lovely lunch eating on the side dining area overlooking the water. All their dishes are amazing but my favorite is their chicken martini. I have even been here for a baby shower and they did a wonderful job.

  • Elisa Bruno-Midili
    1 month ago

    Our first time at Patsy's and everything about it was to our liking. Tasty food, friendly service and a table with a view! Had to try the classic pizza which proved to be classic! Tasty sauce, good crust crunch and not greasy. The roasted eggplant sandwich was delicate and delicious and a departure from the typical eggplant Parmigiana. The sandwich came with a choice of sides and we got the Caesar salad. Our server Krystal was efficient and attentive. Will return to try more menu items. Thank you!

  • Steve Sweeting
    1 month ago

    Food was GREAT, and the service was OUTSTANDING. Our waitress was THE BEST AND HONEST. I offered her a cash tip, and she explained to me that it was already included in the bill since we had a party of 10. We will DEFINITELY dine there again, and I tell everyone about that honest waitress. I wish I remembered her name. We were there on 4/19.

  • Sharnik Anyansi
    3 month ago

    Went for lunch with my mom and good friend. The food was delicious. Tried the Blue Coco drink it was amazing. Our waiter Marco was very attentive to us. We will definitely return.

  • Sonii B
    3 month ago

    I had such a pleasant experience at Patsys Pizzeria New Rochelle. It’s funny I’ve lived in New Rochelle for over twenty years and I’ve passed the restaurant noticing it and kept saying I would visit. Others have said positive things. I finally came to check it out with a friend visiting from out of state. It was a Monday night yet very busy, there was an upbeat energy and warm ambiance about the space. There is plenty of seating so you’re not on top of strangers, which I prefer. The view is lovely looking out on the boats and pretty homes was soothing. Everyone we encountered was pleasant and welcoming. Luis was absolutely amazing. He was friendly, attentive, personable, cheerful, and most important on top of his job. Although he had other tables we felt satisfaction and a personalized touch to his way of service. Our food was fresh and healthy portions. I had the snapper which was cooked to my liking. The bread was soooo delicious. We didn’t have alcohol; however the bar seemed well stocked. I also appreciate that along with the pizza that they’re known for, the kitchen prepares so many other quality dishes. I will definitely be returning in the near future. Thanks again Luis for providing excellent service!

  • B D
    3 month ago

    First time experience. I enjoyed this experience, especially thanks to Suzie (forgive me if it's misspelled), she is literally amazing. I had the carnival cocktail which was tasty with an appetizer of garlic knots (forgot to take a pic) then I had chicken parm with a peach sangria for my entree. For dessert I had zeppoles and they were delicious. I was so full that I had to request a to go container for my entree and dessert. My only negative would be the price of certain items, but not their entire menu. Overall, I definitely left satisfied and I expect to return in the future.

  • Amy Colt
    4 month ago

    My husband and I dined in Patsys in new Rochelle on Monday night. Walked right in and all the staff was so nice and welcoming! Sat by the marina water view in their second dining room which is beautiful to have other events in, very spacious! They have a great wine selection and a full bar to make any cocktail of your liking which is nice. Food was delicious and the service was incredible from start to finish. My husband and I started off with their Homemade meatballs with fresh ricotta cheese on top and a Bib and pear salad, which the waitress was so kind enough to split for us. Then for entrees I had their chicken martini which was so juicy and flavorful, my husband had their famous Short ribs that was recommended to him which he fell in love with. We always save room for dessert and our wonderful waitress Kimberly was raving about having to try their homemade delicious caramel bread pudding, which she was absolutely right about. It’s served warm and comes with vanilla ice cream. They really do treat you like family here! Absolutely amazing experience, They will definitely see us again soon!

Share Your Experience

Your Rating

Discover What Travelers Love About This Place

Real experiences, honest impressions, and insights shared by the Wherevi community to help you explore with confidence.